Mormonism-Unveiled provides a discussion of Latter-day Saint (Mormon) doctrines, practices, and current events from the pro-LDS point of view. In Mormonism-Unveiled, note that I speak only for myself and do not officially speak on behalf of the LDS Church. Get all the facts before you join. Mormonism may not be for everyone - but it might be for YOU.
There is some confusion within a small part of the LDS community today about what should be the baseline for the computation of tithing for members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. There are some, like Alan Rock Waterman of Pure Mormonism, who imply that it should only be 10 percent of "increase" rather than 10 percent of "income". They base their contention on verse 4 of Doctrine & Covenants Section 119, which states in part, "those who have thus been tithed shall pay one-tenth of all their interest annually".
In the Lord’s commandment to the people of this day, tithing is ‘one-tenth of all their interest annually’, which is understood to mean income. The First Presidency has said, “No one is justified in making any other statement than this” (First Presidency letter, 19 Mar. 1970, quoted in the General Handbook of Instructions, 1989, p. 9-1; see also D&C 119).
President Howard W. Hunter stated it this way: “The law is simply stated as ‘one-tenth of all their interest.’ Interest means profit, compensation, increase. It is the wage of one employed, the profit from the operation of a business, the increase of one who grows or produces, or the income to a person from any other source".
This takes all the guesswork out of it. While the LDS leadership leaves open the question as to whether to calculate on the basis of gross income or net income, the defining standard is "income", and "income" is considered interchangeable with "increase". No other interpretation seems appropriate.
Part of the confusion results from the fact that in earlier times, tithing was paid in kind -- a tenth of the herdsman’s increase, a tenth of the farmer’s produce. However, neither the herdsman nor the farmer received an income from the flocks or the land until after it had produced. Likewise today, one does not receive income from a job until one actually gets paid. So one is only expected to tithe on income -- not upon assets.
For business owners, income is defined as what is received AFTER expenses are paid. If a bookstore owner receives $200,000 in gross income during a given year, and takes only $50,000 in personal income, tithing is calculated only upon the income. However, this can become a murky area, which is why the LDS leadership has decided not to rule on whether tithing should be based upon gross income or net income. The decision is left to the individual Church member. And this is wise, considering the complexities of modern financial compensation; while an employee's contribution to a 401k might be considered "income", what about the employer's contribution to the employee's 401k? What about the value of other employment perks, such as health insurance and gym memberships? It's best to leave these questions to the individual Church member rather than for the leadership to micromanage the membership. As the Prophet Joseph Smith once said, "I teach them correct principles, and they govern themselves".
Most bishops will not ask if one is tithing on gross income or net income. So during the annual tithing settlement, or during a worthiness interview for any other purpose, if one is tithing on net income, one can truthfully claim to be paying a full tithing.
In a post on Mormon Mentality entitled "Mormon Mythology: Sons of Perdition", the issue of tithing once again surfaced when the author of the post included the following statement built into the post, "Did they not include the monetary value of company-paid benefits in their tithing calculations?".
This is the first time I've seen any reference to the possibility of including the value of "company-paid benefits" in any calculations involving tithing, and so it prompted me to find out if this was indeed necessary. We already know that tithing is generically defined as one-tenth of one's income, but how does the LDS Church officially define "income"?
The first stop, as always, is the LDS Gospel Library. From there, we obtain the basic doctrinal stance of the Church:
The Bible indicates that God’s people followed the law of tithing anciently; through modern prophets, God restored this law once again to bless His children. To fulfill this commandment, Church members give one-tenth of their income to the Lord through His Church. These funds are used to build up the Church and further the work of the Lord throughout the world. [Ed. Note: This is considered so important that wilful failure to pay a full tithing can lead to denial of temple recommend.]
One of the blessings of membership in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is the privilege of paying tithing. This privilege is a double blessing. By paying tithing, Church members show their gratitude to God for their blessings and their resolve to trust in the Lord rather than in material things. They also help further the work of the Lord in the earth, blessing others of God’s children with the opportunity to learn of Him and to grow in the gospel.
Through the prophet Malachi, the Lord declared:
"Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be meat in mine house, and prove me now herewith, saith the Lord of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it" (Malachi 3:10).
Church members give their tithing donations to local leaders. These local leaders transmit tithing funds directly to the headquarters of the Church, where a council determines specific ways to use the sacred funds. This council is comprised of the First Presidency, the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, and the Presiding Bishopric. Acting according to revelation, they make decisions as they are directed by the Lord. (See D&C 120:1.)
Tithing funds are always used for the Lord's purposes—to build and maintain temples and meetinghouses, to sustain missionary work, to educate Church members, and to carry on the work of the Lord throughout the world.
A good overview, but it still doesn't define "income". Mormon Wikia is also ambiguous on this subject, simply stating "Tithing can be calculated as 10 percent of either net or gross earnings, depending on what each member considers his or her “increase” or income", although the following statement from Chapter 32 of Gospel Principles, "A tithe is one-tenth of our increase. This means that we give one-tenth of all we earn before we pay for our own needs such as food, clothing, and shelter", seems to lend support to basing tithing on gross income. During the October 2006 General Conference, Elder Daniel L. Johnson of the Quorum of the Seventy addressed this issue. In his address, he cited guidance provided by former President Howard W. Hunter, who opined that the term "interest" in the phrase "one-tenth of one's interest" meant profit, compensation, or increase. Written transcript of address HERE; video of address embedded below:
Again, no firm definition of "income" is provided. Perhaps the ambiguity may be attributable to the fact that different nations with different tax systems have different definitions on what constitutes "income". The U.S. tax forms differentiate between gross income and net income. Perhaps the Church leadership has decided to leave this ambiguous in order to allow for these differences.
Unfortunately, this ambiguity can lead to hair-splitting Talmudic-style rows over what constitutes a proper tithe. Thus LDS members end up in danger of placing themselves in positions of judgment over their fellow Saints. It can also lead to excessive agonization during the annual tithing settlement.
Here is my suggested definition for Latter-day Saints resident in the United States, based upon my interpretation (and ONLY my interpretation) of the spirit and intent of the pronunciations by Church leadership: Use gross income as defined by the Internal Revenue Service. Whatever figure you enter on the IRS form you use, simply calculate 10 percent. By using this number, you will automatically account for other variations, such as interest income, capital gains income, and other esoteric sources such as gifts given to you by others. It is my opinion that the Lord intended for us to give Him ten percent of ALL income, and basing our tithing upon IRS-defined gross income not only most closely approximates that goal, but will curtail this endless wrangling about the definition of "income".
Thus if company-paid benefits are not reportable as gross income, then company-paid benefits are not subject to tithing. A good rule of thumb - if it isn't reportable to the government, then it probably doesn't need to be considered reportable to the Church.
Nevertheless, because the Church leadership has deliberately left the definition of "income" ambiguous, this implies that, during tithing settlement, if the bishop asks if you are paying a full tithing, and you're paying 10 percent of net income, you can honestly answer Yes. You make the call; ultimately, it is between you and the Lord. More background on annual tithing settlement HERE.
Method of payment: In areas with modern cash economies, tithing in the form of monetary payment is preferred; most bishops are not equipped to accept "tithing in kind", meaning payment in the form of commodities or labor. Consult your local bishop for further guidance.
Tithes vs. offerings: This paragraph was prompted by a report by an individual that he had written a check for 10 percent, but chose to split it between tithing and the Church's Perpetual Education Fund. Uh-uh; that is NOT considered a full tithing. Tithing is a unique category, as shown on the Church's donation slip HERE. Everything else shown on that slip is an OFFERING; while offerings are always welcome, they do NOT constitute tithing. This is not intended to be picky, but to be precise. Besides, the Lord Himself has said, "My house is a house of order, not a house of confusion".